Third time’s the charm? Alaska voters chose to keep their model election system once again.
With 97 percent of ballots in, the “no” vote on Ballot Measure 2 is leading 53.6 to 46.4 percent. The measure sought to repeal open primaries, ranked choice voting, and dark money disclosures—a wholesale reversal of the election upgrades Alaskans originally voted to adopt in 2020.
This was the second time that detractors of this system ran a ballot measure seeking to dislodge it and failed. The previous repeal measure in 2024 fell short by 743 votes, or about 0.2 percent.
Because Alaskans again voted down the measure, they will retain:
- Unified primaries that allow all voters, including the more than 60 percent who aren’t registered with a party, to participate in the races that, crucially, determine the candidates who move on to the higher-turnout general elections;
- Ranked choice general elections, in which voters rank the top four finishers from the primary; and
- Campaign finance disclosure rules, by which independent expenditure organizations (aka PACs and Super PACs) that spend more than $2,000 in Alaska elections must reveal the true source of their money, and advertisers must disclose if most of their funds come from out-of-state.
Over the four years that these measures have been in place, a few glitches have surfaced that the Alaska Legislature could remedy in a future election reform package. Overall, though, they have delivered Alaskans more transparency, more choice of candidates, and more solutions for people’s everyday lives.
Alaska’s election system has delivered gains for independent-minded voters and bipartisan governance
Alaska’s system has been in place since 2022, and in that time, the state has seen the following positive effects:
- More choice for voters: Since the reform, the trends are clear: voters oust incumbents more often, three or more candidates compete in more races, and legislative races have tighter margins—all of which deliver more choice for Alaskans at the polls.
- More split-ticket voting: In 2022, 52 percent of Alaska’s primary voters split their tickets across parties, showing voters’ real appetite for a mix of leaders to find solutions to their state’s challenges.
- Candidates win with clear mandates: Successful candidates for Alaska’s US House seat in 2022 and 2024 both won with majority support that came from voters of multiple parties and from second-choice rankings, meaning that when they take office, those winners can charge ahead with the measures they trumpeted during their campaigns, knowing the majority of voters are with them.
- More independents and popular moderates can win, better matching Alaskans themselves: Moderate Republican candidates with broad bases of support who likely would have lost under the pre-2020 closed-primary, unranked system have held their seats. These include leaders like US Sen. Lisa Murkowski and Alaska Senate Majority Leader Cathy Giessel. Six independents also won office in 2022—a record for the state and a win for the many Alaskans who identify similarly.
- More solutions Alaskans want: Legislators appear to have more room to act in the interests of their constituents rather than their party. Alaska’s bipartisan coalition, which is unique in the country, formed especially quickly in the Senate in 2023–24, and members pledged to be “moderate and consensus-focused,” enabling them to respond on pressing Alaska issues. In 2025, the legislature was able to override Governor Dunleavy’s unpopular veto of an education spending bill—a vote many Republicans might not have felt they could take without the reformed election system.
- More transparency for Alaskans: Alaskans have a clearer view of who is trying to influence their elections. For example, in 2026, Elon Musk donated $1.5 million to fund the campaign against the current election system and its campaign finance rules. Ironically, without the system’s protections, he might have shrouded his role entirely from voters, robbing them of information that helps them decide their vote.
- Less negative campaigning, more outreach to more voters: Finally, the election system has introduced some incentives for campaigns to reach out to more voters and temper their attacks on opponents. Gubernatorial candidates Treg Taylor and Dave Bronson cross-endorsed one another, and Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins pledged to populate his cabinet with one-third Republicans. Giessel, a moderate Republican and champion of the system, has argued that “it puts the voter at the forefront.”
Additionally, in 2024, 84 percent of Alaska voters reported that they find ranked choice voting simple. The 2026 vote reaffirms what we have observed over the course of four years—the system is working for Alaskans.
Despite its benefits, the system has drawn repeal campaigns and national criticism
Following Mary Peltola’s election to Congress in 2022 and Donald Trump’s disparagement of ranked choice voting, the reform polarized along partisan lines. Republicans mistakenly concluded that ranked choice voting privileges Democrats, even though Peltola was in the lead before additional rankings were considered, Republicans did well in both statewide and down ballot races that cycle, and Nick Begich retook Peltola’s House seat for Republicans in 2024. Nevertheless, Republicans have repeatedly led the chargeto undo Alaska’s election system via ballot measures.
In the waning days of the 2026 campaign season, the New York Times reported that members of the Peltola Senate campaign were involved with recruiting a second candidate named Dan Sullivan to the ballot, with the intent to confuse voters between the incumbent senator (a viable competitor) and an unviable candidate who shared his name. The subsequent uproar led the paper to speculate that the chicanery could be the “death knell” to ranked choice voting in the state, even though it is the nonpartisan primary that allows multiple same-party candidates and ranked choice is proven protection against spoilers. Voters appeared to be unfazed. At the time of writing, the race for Senate remains too close to call, though Peltola is nearing the 50 percent mark in the count.
A final criticism of the system pertained to the high-profile candidate dropouts post-primary. Since 2022, election reformers and ranked choice voting proponents, Sightline included, have disapproved of the way Alaska Republicans have pressured trailing candidates to drop out of the general election, reducing choices for voters. This year, Democrats did the same thing: serious left-of-center candidates for US House, Senate, and governor all withdrew from their races or ceased campaigning in the lead-up to the general election, and many observers called foul. Candidate withdrawals and party consolidation are certainly features of “pick one” elections as well, but expanded choice on the ballot is central to the appeal of a ranked choice system.
Lawmakers can still improve the system
With Alaska’s election system here to stay, lawmakers can start considering how it might be improved. No policy is perfect, and some criticisms of the system mentioned above have merit. A few tweaks or some more substantial upgrades could make a difference in ensuring voters have the greatest possible say among the best candidates. Improvements to the system may also future-proof it against more repeal efforts down the road.
Below are some ideas that range from modest improvements to significant overhauls. All have tradeoffs, differing levels of feasibility, and downsides that deserve deep analysis, which Sightline intends to explore in greater detail in future articles. For now, we hope they stimulate conversation among election reform advocates who want to see the best possible version of the system come to life.
Add a signature requirement or increase fees to get on the primary ballot
With $100, anyone can get on the statewide primary ballot in Alaska. This low barrier allowed candidates like Eric Hafner, who is serving a federal prison sentence and has never lived in Alaska, to make it to the general election ballot in 2024 and again in 2026. To fix this problem, lawmakers could raise the filing fee or enact a signature requirement for candidates to be listed on the ballot. A set of Alaska state legislators are pursuing a policy to this effect now.
Display party endorsements of candidates on ballots
Alaska’s ballots today indicate only a candidate’s self-selected party affiliation—not which parties select (or endorse) them in return. Dan J. Sullivan, the same-name challenger from Petersburg, was a registered Republican. This made it potentially more difficult for voters to distinguish him from Dan S. Sullivan, the Republican incumbent. Allowing parties to indicate their official endorsed pick on the ballot could reduce uncertainty and provide clearer signals to voters who rely on party identification to make informed choices.1
Parties are unpopular, though, and some champions of Alaska’s system believe they already get too many special privileges with regards to elections. Some are also concerned that independent-minded candidates who buck the party line would be less likely to succeed, and that this change would undercut the purpose of the open primary. These are tradeoffs that policy makers would need to weigh against helping voters identify who they agree with most.
Fund consistent voter education on ranking
In the November 2024 general election, 55 percent of Alaska voters did not rank any contest on their ballots. Instead, they selected only one top choice and left the other preferences blank (also called bullet voting). Bullet voting is a legitimate way to express preferences (for example, if a voter only likes one candidate in the race), but in a ranked choice system, doing so surrenders a ballot’s full power.
In 2022, only 18 percent of Alaskans bullet voted in every race. Several factors could explain the lower rates that first year, including the state’s vigorous voter education campaign that included multimedia, multilingual explainers, ads, mock elections, town halls, and more. This type of energetic outreach might remind voters about the power of their ballot and reduce bullet voting. Lawmakers could ensure voter education about ranked choice is a routine budget item.
Disallow candidate dropouts after primaries
Party consolidation is likely a strategic response to the low levels of ranking mentioned above. If voters don’t rank, then a ranked choice election effectively collapses into a “pick one” election, which is vulnerable to spoilers. Sightline will discuss this problem further in future articles, but one solution is for lawmakers to disallow dropping post-primary. (Of course, candidates could still cease campaigning or coordinate with the strongest candidate of their block to urge voters to rank them in their preferred order.) This change would reduce scenarios where the general election ballots include candidates who are fifth- or sixth-place finishers with little support. The legislature could also institute a minimum threshold of votes, say five percent, that a candidate must earn in the primary to get to the general, further discouraging non-viable candidates.
Disallowing dropouts, though, might just shift ballot stacking and consolidation activities to pre-primary. There’s also the question of what happens if the candidate who wins no longer wants to hold the office.
Reduce ballot exhaustion and bullet voting through delegated rankings
To address both bullet voting and ballot exhaustion, lawmakers could enact a more radical policy of “delegated rankings.” The legislature could require candidates to publicly release official ranking lists that display how they would rank their competitors. Voters would have the option to make their own ranking selections as usual, or, if they only ranked one, their top choice’s list would fill the remaining slots. In so doing, voters would delegate their rankings to the candidate they trust most. If a voter did not want their top candidate’s choices filled on their ballot, they could check a box indicating that they want their ballot to exhaust if their top choice does not make it to subsequent rounds. (Kristin Eberhard proposed a version of this solution for Sightline in 2022.) Alternatively, a voter could “opt-in” to having their preferred candidate’s list populate their ballot.
This approach would substantially overhaul to the existing system and likely create different opportunities for gamesmanship, but it could also improve candidate incentives and strengthen voters’ voices.
Continuing to deliver for Alaskans
With themselves to thank, Alaskans will continue to reap the benefits of their now-standard election system, and Sightline will continue to study its effects and suggest refinements. With a few thoughtful upgrades to the existing system, the Alaska legislature can ensure voters can voice their preferences for the best selection of candidates, and that the state continues to shine as an example of better elections.

