Takeaways
- Plurality winner elections plague Montana politics. In contests like the four-way 2026 race for US Senate, it’s not clear whether the winner had majority support.
- Democrats and Republicans strategically back third parties in endless attempts to siphon votes from their opponents, which only adds to the turmoil.
- Better models from Montana’s past and present—that is, fusion voting and top-two primaries—can mitigate the dreaded spoiler effect. Other states use variations on runoff elections to do the same.
Spoiled again.
For the third time this century, one of Montana’s US Senate seats will go to a candidate whom most voters cast ballots against. In Big Sky Country, split-vote outcomes in contests like 2026’s four-way Senate race cause recurring headaches for candidates, parties, and voters alike. Cycle after cycle, Democratic or Republican activists scheme to sink or support minor-party candidates as spoilers, compounding the pain.
The suffering starts with Montana’s unfair plurality winner rules (aka “first past the post”). Candidates only need to collect more votes than anyone else—a plurality—to win. So, when two or more aspiring officeholders divvy up a majority voter base, a third can win without popular support: a recipe for campaign chaos.
Luckily, reformers seeking relief have no shortage of options. Montana has a couple of time-tested treatments right at home: fusion voting and top-two primaries. Other states have whipped up their own remedies with variations on runoff elections.
A vote-splitting headache in 2026
Montanans had an early warning that a multi-candidate migraine might be coming on. In early 2026, former Senator Jon Tester, a Democrat, allegedly called his party’s brand “poison” and backed independent Seth Bodnar, a former University of Montana president, in Bodnar’s run for Senate.
So it began.
Rumors and accusations divided Treasure State Democrats over how—or whether—to move forward when Bodnar and their nominee stood to split a similar voter base. To deter a strong Democrat from running, incumbent Senator Steve Daines pulled a last-minute primary swap-out with fellow Republican Kurt Alme, who easily won the GOP nomination.
Countering Republican money in the Democratic primary, Tester supporters propped up eventual nominee Alani Bankhead, perhaps hoping she’d step down and support Bodnar. She refused. Bankhead and Bodnar spent their summers playing chicken over whether either would drop out, while Kyle Austin, a Libertarian at odds with his purported party, sought to siphon support from Alme.
In the end, all four candidates stayed in the race. A majority of Montana voters divided their support between the three non-GOP candidates, and Alme coasted to victory with a cool 48 percent, echoing Senator Tester’s 2006 and 2012 split-vote wins. Had Montana had a majority-winner rule in place, the outcomes might or might not have been different, but Montanans at least could have felt confident they collectively sent their preferred candidates to office.
Parties squabble over spoilers instead of seeking majority support
Head-spinning hubbub over vote splitting is an unfortunate and persistent feature of modern Montana politics. Rather than trying to tailor campaigns to a majority of Montanans, Democratic and Republican heavyweights seem stuck in a never-ending tug-of-war over candidates who might spoil close contests for the other major party:
- In 2024, Donald Trump publicly pressured Libertarian Sid Daoud to drop out of the state’s crucial US Senate election. Democrats sued to boot Green Party candidate Robert Barb, who had previously received Republican backing, from the ballot.
- In 2022, the Democratic nominee in Montana’s western congressional district, Monica Tranel, held regular forums with Libertarian John Lamb and urged news outlets to include him in debates. Right-wing outlets accused the two of colluding to spoil the election.
- In 2020, the Republican Party surreptitiously sponsored a $100,000 signature-gathering effort to qualify Green Party candidates for the ballot, unbeknownst to hundreds of voters who signed their names.
- In 2018, Democrats challenged the Green Party’s ballot-qualified status in court. Libertarian Rick Breckenridge dropped out of the US Senate race after dark money mailers sought to boost his candidacy to help incumbent Senator Jon Tester.
When the state legislature reconvenes in 2027, leaders on both sides of the aisle have a choice: force exhausted Montanan voters to keep suffering through activists’ endless attempts to spoil elections… or face the plurality-winner problem head-on.
Montana’s home remedies: Good old-fashioned fusion voting and top-two primaries
Thankfully, relief for regular campaign pains is within reach. Reformers could revive a classic from Montana’s past: fusion voting, which lets two or more parties back the same candidate so they can share their bases and resources. Alternatively, limiting general election contests to two participants, like Montana does for nonpartisan offices, would also make plurality winner outcomes unlikely.
Fusion voting: Montana’s heirloom approach
Long ago, Montana had an optional pressure release valve for crowded and competitive races. Fusion voting once allowed parties with similar interests to nominate the same candidates rather than eat into each other’s vote share.
Take for example Montana’s 1896 gubernatorial election. In the previous cycle, Republican John E. Rickards won control of the governor’s office with just over 40 percent of the vote; Democratic and Populist Party candidates had split the majority. Learning from their mistake, the latter two parties co-nominated Robert B. Smith in 1896 and won with a whopping 72 percent vote majority. (Republicans of the era also found success fusing with the Populists in North Carolina and Texas.)
Fusion voting isn’t currently legal in Montana or most other states, though it could be ripe for a comeback.1 Parties by no means have to cross-nominate candidates, but the practice can create win-win scenarios when they do. Major parties can rest assured their base will stick together, while smaller parties’ labels on the ballot and campaign infrastructure give them a boost. For their part, smaller parties can use the fusion option as leverage to influence major party policy, even if they don’t win any contests by themselves.
Top-two primaries: The not-so-secret spoiler solution
In Montana, nonpartisan elections like judicial contests sport an anti-spoiler safeguard. When three or more candidates participate in a nonpartisan primary, only the two with the most votes move on to the general election. (Such was the case for both Montana Supreme Court positions up for grabs in 2024.) Barring an unusually successful write-in campaign, a two-candidate general election contest leaves no room for spoilers.2
California and Washington have adapted the same practice for partisan contests: all candidates, regardless of party, run together in a unified primary, and the two most popular vote-getters advance to the final ballot. If top-two had been in place for Montana’s US Senate contest, Alme, Austin, Bankhead, Bodnar, and all other contenders would have a chance to make their case to all of Montana in the primary. Then, during the general election, Montanans would have picked between the two strongest primary performers (perhaps an Alme-Bodnar or Alme-Bankhead matchup). Without other general election candidates around to split the vote, one would have walked away with a majority—and a clear mandate. Montana legislators proposed variations on top-two partisan elections in 2013, 2015, 2023, and 2025.
When compared with partisan primaries like Montana’s, all-candidate unified primaries are a step in the right direction. Researchers have found that the top-two model lessens the impact of big money in politics. Unified primaries tend to increase turnout and attract voters who vote more like the general electorate.
Additionally, the all-party concept means heavily left- or right-leaning districts can produce competitive, two-Democrat or two-Republican general elections respectively, rather than a pointless Democrat-versus-Republican matchup where the winner is essentially a foregone conclusion. Since California and Washington adopted top-two, one in every seven legislative primaries produced same-party outcomes.3
The top-two model is not without its flaws. Activists sometimes elevate controversial candidates who make for weak general election opponents. On rare occasions, when a dominant party sufficiently splits the vote, the two winners who advance aren’t a good fit for the electorate. The model also tends to disadvantage independent and minor-party candidates.4 Still, top-two primaries could mitigate general election vote-splitting in Montana.
Majority-winner methods from beyond Montana
Montana is hardly the first or only place in North America to suffer from spoiler sorrows. Other states employ their own homegrown renditions of general election runoffs to make plurality winner elections unlikely to impossible.
Georgia and Mississippi use delayed runoffs. If no candidate clears 50 percent of the vote, a second election between the two highest vote-getters takes place a few weeks later. The delayed runoff model is a bit of a bitter pill: it was originally a tool that racist Southern Democrats used to stay in power, though it may have become less discriminatory in practice over time. Still, second-round elections tend to attract low turnout, cost a lot of money, and strain underresourced election offices.
Louisiana’s runoffs go down easier. Some Bayou State contests, including those for governor and the state legislature, don’t have traditional partisan primaries. Instead, all candidates from all parties run for election together, and runoffs occur only if no one reaches a majority. Though the Louisiana model has pleasant side effects—improved governance and tamped-down polarization—lawmakers passed overwhelmingly unpopular legislation in 2024 that migrated congressional offices, among others, to partisan primaries.
Finally, Alaska and Maine skip the double dose of voting and instead employ instant runoffs, also known as ranked choice voting. Despite high-profile claims to the contrary, ranked ballots do not advantage any one party; rather, they dampen the spoiler effect. Alabama, Arkansas, Georgia, Louisiana, Mississippi, and South Carolina all use ranked ballots to make sure active-duty military voters can cast votes in runoff elections from overseas.
Pros, cons, and misconceptions aside, any one of the above options could increase public confidence that Montana’s US Senators have the support of most Montanans. That’s not to say Senator Tester or Senator-elect Alme necessarily would have lost their respective contests under different rules; fusion voting, top-two primaries, and runoffs simply can help stave off split-vote headaches and provide clearer outcomes—results surely all Big Sky state residents would appreciate.
Appendix: Additional Resources
Fusion voting
- New America: What We Know About Fusion Voting
- Protect Democracy: Fusion Voting, Explained
Top-two primaries
- American Enterprise Institute: Conservatives Should Look More Closely at Systemic Election Reforms
- Johns Hopkins School of Government and the University of Chicago Center for Effective Government: Top-Two Primary Elections
Runoff elections
- Oxford Academic: When the Second Vote Decides: A Comprehensive Analysis of Runoff Elections in the United States
- Unite America Institute: Louisiana’s Long-Term Election Experiment
Instant runoffs and ranked ballots
- American Bar Association:What We Know About Ranked Choice Voting, Updated for 2025
- R Street Institute: R Street on RCV

